The following warnings occurred:
Warning [2] Undefined property: MyLanguage::$archive_pages - Line: 2 - File: printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code PHP 8.3.37 (Linux)
File Line Function
/inc/class_error.php 153 errorHandler->error
/printthread.php(287) : eval()'d code 2 errorHandler->error_callback
/printthread.php 287 eval
/printthread.php 117 printthread_multipage



Off The Leash
News From Australia! - Printable Version

+- Off The Leash (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community)
+-- Forum: The Showground (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community/forum-6.html)
+--- Forum: Pre 2020 Show Results & Photos (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community/forum-22.html)
+--- Thread: News From Australia! (/thread-9184.html)

Pages: 1 2


News From Australia! - Hashanah - 03-03-2006

I think you'll find that in most countries the Shih Tzu competes in the Utility and Non Sporting Group... When did the "Toy" issue raise it's head in this discussion(?)...



(As a long standing exhibitor of Japanese Chin and a Championship Show Judge of the 'Australian' Toy Group) I personally think your comments pertaining to the "Toy" factor reveal an ignorance on your behalf... There are many breeds in the Toy Group that have "purpose"... Take for example the Cavalier which is basically a small Gundog whatever way you look at it... Being in the Toy Group has not altered it's size, substance or "function"... In fact there are many breeds in the Toy Group have have specific functions even more so than the Shih Tzu breed...



I do not for a moment feel the Shih Tzu belongs in the Toy Group, but the point I would like to make is that breeds change form because of people, not as a direct result of being in any one particular Group...



The inference that if one sticks a bow in a topknot will lead down a path to "Toy dogs lacking type, substance, and purpose" is ridiculous... Also the inference that being in the Toy Group leads to an increase in presentation levels is also ridiculous... Some of the most highly presented breeds in dogdom I think actually reside in the (UK) Utility Group...



Again, people change breeds, not bows, people change breeds, not hairspray, people change breeds, not group placement, again people change breeds...



JMHO

Phillip


News From Australia! - blisld - 03-03-2006

sorry ..



but then why is the shihtzu classed as a company or compagnionship dog here???



i cannot imagine a shiddie as a toy or utility dog...



for me personally a "toy" is very tiny ....



and "utility" is a working dog big or small..



or maybe i haven't understood the discution!!!


News From Australia! - Lucy - 03-03-2006

Quote:I think you'll find that in most countries the Shih Tzu competes in the Utility and Non Sporting Group... When did the "Toy" issue raise it's head in this discussion(?)...

The inference that if one sticks a bow in a topknot will lead down a path to "Toy dogs lacking type, substance, and purpose" is ridiculous... Also the inference that being in the Toy Group leads to an increase in presentation levels is also ridiculous... Some of the most highly presented breeds in dogdom I think actually reside in the (UK) Utility Group...







I know the Shih Tzu is a utility here (and most countries) but isn't it classed as a toy in the states? It's also my understanding that most of the bows etc. started in the states too.

JMHO


News From Australia! - Redhall - 03-03-2006

I read some time ago that with every litter born a breed evolves, even if minutely. This seems reasonable to me - and - as with native show ponies in this country, the way we keep, feed and generally administer to them alters them. Native ponies that compete at the top have become more "showy", less able to live "naturally" mainly due to the way they are fed, rugged up (instead of facing the weather) etc etc. And so with dogs, we feed them differently often with complete foods, most are kept indoors and not in kennels all these things alter, however slowly, a breed. Presentation is, in my opinion, only a small part of what a dog is all about, a good dog is a good dog whether it has no preparation or ribbons in it's hair. But I acknowledge that to compete on a 'level playing field' preparation is a vital part of showing. I definitely wouldn't want to use bows - I think the expertise to do it well enough evades me! But if that is the way a dog is shown in another country or even here, then that's the way it is. The dog itself remains the same.



Anyway - WELL DONE GUCCI!! Another feather in your illustrious cap! Big Hugs from the Redhall Gang.


News From Australia! - Tam and Taffie - 03-03-2006

[quote name='Redhall' post='31347' date='Mar 3 2006, 12:48 PM']Presentation is, in my opinion, only a small part of what a dog is all about, a good dog is a good dog whether it has no preparation or ribbons in it's hair.[/quote]



Ahhhh, refreshing. I couldn't agree more Gloria <img src='http://www.shihtzuclub.co.uk/forums/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt='Big Grin' /> <img src='http://www.shihtzuclub.co.uk/forums/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/claps.gif' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':C' />


News From Australia! - Adam - 03-03-2006

Quote:The inference that if one sticks a bow in a topknot will lead down a path to "Toy dogs lacking type, substance, and purpose" is ridiculous
Not necessarily. A lot of the basis for raising the issue of the toy group here is that in the US, Shih Tzu are a toy breed and most of the impetus for bows and, in my view, other excessive adornments has come from there. At the end of the day it is worthwhile to remember that this whole subject is a question of degree. Good handlers everywhere try to present their dogs so as to minimise their faults and emphasise their attributes. The sticking point comes in where to draw the line. Is it ok to use the topknot arrangement (aided by cotton wool in the odd case) to hide the fact that your dog has a poor head for example? Is it ok to use laquer in the hope that the judge thinks twice about examining the head fully for fear of ruining a creation that can sometimes take an hour or more to make? Is it ok to race your dog around the ring to hide movement faults? I am giving extreme examples but if exhibitors can get away with that sort of thing and inferior dogs start to win because of it then the breed is being done a great disservice because it lowers the overall standard. When the importance of presentation takes over from the importance of type then it is a negative thing in my view.



Quote:Again, people change breeds, not bows, people change breeds, not hairspray, people change breeds, not group placement, again people change breeds...



People put in the bows, the hairspray and what have you. It's a bit like saying guns don't kill people, people kill people. Obviously it is true but it misses the point.



This is one of those things where there is a danger of just shouting past each other which is a pity because I don't think the relative viewpoints expressed here are that far apart.


News From Australia! - Hashanah - 03-03-2006

Adam you said "The sticking point comes in where to draw the line. Is it ok to use the topknot arrangement (aided by cotton wool in the odd case) to hide the fact that your dog has a poor head for example? Is it ok to use lacquer in the hope that the judge thinks twice about examining the head fully for fear of ruining a creation that can sometimes take an hour or more to make? Is it ok to race your dog around the ring to hide movement faults?"...



In this instance I am totally bewildered as to why one would show at all then if this was the way one felt, as clearly you place no confidence in the judges ability to evaluate an exhibit appropriately???... The onus is after all on the Judge to find fault/s and reward virtues to whatever degree...



Phillip

Ps Cotton wool in the topknot???... I have never heard anything so ridiculous!!!... I would think it would be significantly harder to use cotton wool in the topknot than simply attaching a bow... There really must be some extraordinary groomers out there if this is the case... And how can this all be occurring whilst the breed in the Utility Group, I thought only such adornments came with Toy Group influences???...

PPs How many times have we seen beautiful moving dogs who are just so happy to be shown, moving out, then other exhibitors crying out "oh so and so is moving their dog too fast to hide this or that"... Construction (with temperament) plays a HUGE role in movement, more so than a handlers influence... A poorly constructed dog cannot move out, no matter how hard a handler tries because they are simply not capable of it... A bit like Mrs Smith stating "Oh but fluffy doesn't want to hold her head up when we walk", when the reality of it is fluffy is incapable of holding her head up (as a result of her assemblage), that's why she doesn't...


News From Australia! - blisld - 03-03-2006

well said phillip!!!

a bit technical for me but i do understand what you mean...



and i agree with you!



the cotton wool story i have heard about that. to me that's cheating.



i haven't as yet found or seen a judge who hesitates to feel a dogs head because of the topknot.



and as i said before, you cannot judge a good shihtzu just by looking at it. you have to "feel" it or touch. the long flowing coat can in fact hide certains defaults.



in other words the judge uses his hands to "look" at the dog. and the way a dog walks automaticaly will show you his construction!



and in the same way you cannot force a dog to walk correctly if he doesn't want or if he not in the mood to do so. the same applies to the way he (the dog) carries his tail! i have seen some gorgeous shiddies who once in the ring let their tails hanging down behind... the owner then tries to assure the judge that he or she (the dog) is tired or not on form or not feeling well or other excuses.


News From Australia! - DebJon - 03-03-2006

Quote:(As a long standing exhibitor of Japanese Chin and a Championship Show Judge of the 'Australian' Toy Group) I personally think your comments pertaining to the "Toy" factor reveal an ignorance on your behalf... There are many breeds in the Toy Group that have "purpose"... Take for example the Cavalier which is basically a small Gundog whatever way you look at it... Being in the Toy Group has not altered it's size, substance or "function"... In fact there are many breeds in the Toy Group have have specific functions even more so than the Shih Tzu breed...





Reading through Debbies post I can`t make out where she said that the Toy group does not have a purpose, but on the whole the toys were developed as companion or lap dogs due to their size and substance and this is the only group here in the UK where bows are accepted in the show ring.



When you refer to the Cavalier ( King Charles Spaniels) I believe these were developed as lap dogs. Whereas the King Charles Spaniels are little gundogs who were crossed with toy dogs from the East. Perhaps these breeds are different in Australia.



Once again if your dog is non competitive unless you go for a more exaggerated presentation style then the judges are being influenced. This might be why UK dogs are thought of so highly.



jmho



john


News From Australia! - Hashanah - 03-03-2006

[quote name='DebJon' post='31530' date='Mar 4 2006, 10:09 AM']When you refer to the Cavalier ( King Charles Spaniels) I believe these were developed as lap dogs. Whereas the King Charles Spaniels are little gundogs who were crossed with toy dogs from the East. Perhaps these breeds are different in Australia.[/quote]



I think you're getting confused, as a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel and a King Charles Spaniels are distinct from one another, and I think you are misquoting one as the other(?). I would think the King Charles Spaniel as a "little Gundog" as you say, would have an terrible time flushing out/carrying their catch considering they are a brachycephalic breed and extremely undershot... As an expert I am sure you will clarify this for me...



The general point is simple Mr. Wilett, as Gloria said previously Top Dogs do consistently well irrespective of country, grooming, group placement etc...



Lets leave it at that...



Regards,

Phillip


News From Australia! - DebJon - 03-04-2006

Quote:I think you're getting confused, as a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel and a King Charles Spaniels are distinct from one another, and I think you are misquoting one as the other(?). I would think the King Charles Spaniel as a "little Gundog" as you say, would have an terrible time flushing out/carrying their catch considering they are a brachycephalic breed and extremely undershot... As an expert I am sure you will clarify this for me...
Perhaps we should move to a toy chat group. Those of you with a UK Kennel Club Breed standard can read up for themselves and find out if it is the Cavalier as you stated is a little gundog or the KCS as being quoted there as '' Basically these were little gundogs''



Yes Glorias' post was very balanced and contained some very valid observations .......



Quote:I definitely wouldn't want to use bows



At least we agree that the ST should remain in the utility group.



john


News From Australia! - Susanne - 03-04-2006

Quote:Ps Cotton wool in the topknot???... I have never heard anything so ridiculous!!!...
Ridiculous as it may sound it has and is still being done, in the TOY GROUP in other countries and NOT in the UK.

Quote:Construction (with temperament) plays a HUGE role in movement, more so than a handlers influence... A poorly constructed dog cannot move out, no matter how hard a handler tries because they are simply not capable of it...

Construction with temperment does play a part in movement but I disagree that a poorly constructed dog cannot move out. If you have a shih-tzu constructed 'greyhound' like with a very narrow ribcage and narrow throughout which I have seen appear frequently in the breed then they are going to move too quickly round the ring and not have 'true' shih-tzu movement - rather more like a lhasa apso which is unacceptable.





I do agree with Gloria that presentation is only a small part of what a dog is all about but I personally have experienced judges when i bred and exhibited miniature poodles who did not examine the skull properly for fear of ruining the top knot or the coat in general. I have then put no confidence in this judge's ability to evaluate my exhibit appropriately and therefore have never exhibited under that judge again.



Quote:Once again if your dog is non competitive unless you go for a more exaggerated presentation style then the judges are being influenced. This might be why UK dogs are thought of so highly.

I agree.


News From Australia! - Hashanah - 03-04-2006

[quote name='DebJon' post='31543' date='Mar 4 2006, 11:24 AM']Those of you with a UK Kennel Club Breed standard can read up for themselves and find out if it is the Cavalier as you stated is a little gundog or the KCS as being quoted there as '' Basically these were little gundogs''



john[/quote]



Actually Mr Willet I stated
Quote:There are many breeds in the Toy Group that have "purpose"... Take for example the Cavalier which is basically a small Gundog whatever way you look at it...
...



Where did I mention the KCS anywhere here let alone as being a little Gundog as you claim???... Please don't twist my words...

Also, with reference to the Cavalier (which again is not a King Charles Spaniel Mr Wilett) the comment was made in light of taking the dog at first glance, not from a history or Standards perspective ie it's phenotype without needing to know anything about the breed... Does it still look like a small, refined, adorned with extras, over coated, unsubstantial, dog without purpose that cannot move???... Has being in the Toy Group modified it's substance, bone, size etc... certainely not... Do you understand what I am trying to say here???...



**edit



If you actually go back and read my posts, I am agreeing with you that I feel the Shih Tzu should never be placed in the Toy Group, I am agreeing that I do not feel bows are neccessary (but give people the choice if possible), I am agreeing with you that I feel hairspray is uneccessary (but give people the choice if possible), but you don't seem to see this???... **edit

Enough...



Phillip


News From Australia! - DebJon - 03-04-2006

Philip I have no idea where those comments are coming from, this is all too bizarre for me!!! **edit** This has all started from a simple comment, 'Gucci looks so different now' no inference was made to the detriment?

Debbie


News From Australia! - Adam - 03-04-2006

I still think the pair of you are rather shouting past each other here.



I think these sorts of topics are important and need to be discussed. These issues are fundamental to the future of the breed and were one of my motivations for setting up OTL in the first place.



This one has gone as far as it is going to go for the time being so I have closed it. Please don't carry it on in another topic immediately. It might be an idea for everyone to go back, re-read what has been posted and see if you can find another 'take' on what has been said. I'm sure this subject will come up again.



I don't think I have yet said 'Well Done' to you and Gucci btw Phillip. It is good to see a UK bred dog doing well abroad and hopefully it will raise the international profile of UK dogs to the benefit of the breed at large.