![]() |
|
Stc Of Scotland 2007 - Critique - Printable Version +- Off The Leash (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community) +-- Forum: The Showground (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community/forum-6.html) +--- Forum: Show Reports (Critiques) (https://www.theshihtzuclub.co.uk/community/forum-23.html) +--- Thread: Stc Of Scotland 2007 - Critique (/thread-5423.html) |
Stc Of Scotland 2007 - Critique - Adam - 06-23-2007 Judge : Mrs Susan Crossley This critique reflects the judge's opinion based on what they saw on the day of the show. I was very pleased to judge the Shih Tzu Club of Scotlandâs Championship show. Thank you to the Officers and Committee for inviting me. Not having judged for a while I was anxious to see if the breed had altered much. It has in some ways. There is still a great gulf between the top 15% of very good Shih Tzu and the bottom 20% being quite poor. There are still problems but I would say that on the whole they are different problems than we experienced years ago. This has probably come about because of large numbers of imports available at stud which has mixed up bloodlines and diluted the type of Shih Tzu I was looking for. Genetic diversity is highly desirable but a lack of consistency of type is not. Fronts are narrower, so too the back ends and the balance has changed in that they are higher on the leg and shorter in body. I do feel that this will cause us problems in future as a large round head coming out of a square body invites whelping difficulties as already seen in Bulldogs and Pugs to name but a few. Presentation is now generally excellent, but remember, a fit healthy, good type Shih Tzu is far more important than a huge coat if the Shih Tzu is to move forward in a healthy state. Minor Puppy Dog 1st Whispers In Gold at Brienta Very good size, excellent type, lovely head & tail carriage. Movement very relaxed, kept a lovely outline on the move. 2nd Tansingh Shoot From The Hip Well grown puppy, good head & expression, lovely tail, very good mouth. Moved well. Puppy Dog 1st Shantrionna Seventh Heaven Beautiful head & expression, perfect mouth, lovely balance, excellent tail, lovely coat. BPIS 2nd Tameron Mr Eternity Excellent balance, tail carriage & size. Moved exuberantly, managed the floor better than 1 but preferred head of 1 Junior Dog 1st Kimevan No Ordinary Boy Good size, correct head, good tail, correct movement. Novice Dog 1st Shantrionna Seventh Heaven Beautiful head & expression, perfect mouth, lovely balance, excellent tail, lovely coat. BPIS 2nd Kimevan No Ordinary Boy Good size, correct head, good tail, correct movement. Under Graduate Dog 1st Thaisu Back To Bedlam Handsome boy not yet at his best. Large round head, correct expression, good mouth, lovely balance & tail carriage 2nd Shirshaun Flash Gordon at Kilbrogan Very handsome dog, good movement, tail & balance but not entire. Post Graduate Dog 1st Zuthis Fact Not Fiction among Carlita Lovely size & balance, very good head, excellent coat, could carry less weight. Moved correctly but could go with more zest. 2nd Shirshaun Dirty Den Very correct little dog, very good head & expression, good balance & tail carriage. Moved correctly but not always giving his best. Minor Limit Dog 1st Chiaru I'm A Celebrity Excellent head & expression, lovely balance, good coat. A bit skittish on the day so didn't give his best. 2nd Mirazian Artist Impression JW Head & expression not as exquisite as 1 but a lot calmer. Good coat & condition, moved very correctly. Excellent tail carriage. Limit Dog 1st Ch. Tameron Mr Kenzo Excellent large round head, very good expression and mouth. Excellent balance & tail carriage. Very good coat. Great presentation & handling. Very good extension in back movement. CC & BIS 2nd Permac No White Collar Black dog, very good head & expression. SLightly higher on the leg than 1 so I preferred the balance of 1. Good tail & correct movement. Open Dog 1st Ch. Cradarr He's A Cracker at Krisquest Lovely little dog. Exquisite head & expression, lovely balance, gorgeous tail, excellent coat, moved well. A very worthy Champion. Res CC 2nd Permac Firecracker at Kilbrogan A very nice dog. Good head & expression. Higher on the leg than 1 hence I preferred the balance of 1. Good coat & tail Minor Puppy Bitch 1st Rossvale She's A Model Exquisite head & expression, lovely balance & body shape. Good tail, very good movement. Best MPIS 2nd Tansingh Miss L Fire Very good size & balance, excellent mouth & very good head & tail carriage. Correct movement 3rd Lauramist Angelis Very attractive puppy, good head & expression, nice size & balance VHC Zuthis Bee Dazzled By Attractive puppy, pretty head, good tail, moved well. Puppy Bitch 1st Shirshaun Pansy Potter Very good honest puppy, good in all areas, no significant weaknesses 2nd Tsantha Double Trouble at Sazkey A small one. Gorgeous head & expression, lovely balance, sound mover Junior Bitch 1st Rossvale Miss Dynamite at Thaisu Very good head & expression, excellent balance, good size, good neck, high tail, excellent movement 2nd Shantrionna Fairy Maiden Another lovely size & balance, very good head, expression & mouth, lovely tail & coat. Not as good as 1 on the move Maiden Bitch 1st Zuthis Bee Dazzled By Attractive puppy, pretty head, good tail, moved well. Novice Bitch 1st Shirshaun Pansy Potter Very good honest puppy, good in all areas, no significant weaknesses 2nd Lauramist Angelis Very attractive puppy, good head & expression, nice size & balance Under Graduate Bitch 1st Betranna The Enchantress Solid black, a colour which everyone knows I am fond of. Very good head & expression. Lovely balance - so important in a solid. Correct tail set, moved the best in this class 2nd Betranna Only Make Believe at Permac Lovely head & expression, good body shape & correct tail. Lost out on hind movement 3rd Shantrionna Fairy Maiden Another lovely size & balance, very good head, expression & mouth, lovely tail & coat. Not as good as 1 on the move Post Graduate Bitch 1st Hii Hazel with Jardhu Very pretty bitch, excellent size & balance, good head, expression & mouth. Lovely tail and moved very well. 2nd Shirshaun Angel Of The North Another pretty bitch. Very similar in many aspects but did not have the get up and go of 1. Minor Limit Bitch 1st Tsantha Sunny Side Up at Sazkey A lovely bitch to handle. There is nothing you can actually say is wrong with her, everything is in place, nothing exaggerated. Excellent balance, lovely tail carriage matching well carried neck. Lovely head & expression, fabulous mouth, beautiful coat, very sound front & rear. Unfortunately she will only do as much as she wants to, which was enough for BCC but not to take BIS from the dog. 2nd Mirazian Nokkia Socks Off Older bitch, lovely head, expression & mouth. Good level topline, very nice tail carriage, sound mover Limit Bitch 1st Rossvale Miss Scarlett Exquisite head & expression, lovely size & balance, excellent tail, very well presented & handled. RCC 2nd Yakee Show Me Heaven Lovely bitch to go over, very good head & expression, dark eyes, very good size & balance. Moved soundly. |