Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Crufts 2012 - Critique
#1
Crufts - Shih Tzu – Judge Mrs. Pam Woodbridge



I have not shown for 10 years or judged for nearly 5. I did not attend any shows in the previous 18 months to this appointment as I did not want any preconceived ideas before I went into the ring.



Firstly as to ring etiquette, you should not under any circumstances put a dog on the table covered in excrement, if your dog has an accident of this sort tell the steward and ask if the judge can be told in order that can leave the ring to clean the dog. Don’t forget that the judge is touching other dogs after yours, mouths etc.



I never showed my bitches in season unless they were all but finished – If you decide to show a bitch in full season then be prepared to clean up after it don’t leave the table covered for the person behind you to stand their bitch in the mess.



Don’t be sarcastic to the judge this is not a good idea, especially doing it to me – I was going to ask a person to move their bitch in another triangle before she moved in a straight line bent down to stop the dog, and looked into its face and was asked in a particular nasty tone “don’t you want her to move up and down then”, I did not ask for the triangle to be rerun!



I know my withholding cards did not go down well, that is to be expected. I felt that the quality of that particular class was so bad that I could not place 1[sup]st[/sup] and 2[sup]nd[/sup]. But, and it is a big but, someone qualified those dogs, this is the most worrying thing for this breed – I know number are down and that sometimes judges only have 3 or 4 in a class, but this does not mean you have to place unworthy dogs, have the courage of your convictions and do not place dogs just because you have cards to give out. It makes people showing these dogs, especially novice exhibitors, think they have something they do not.



As to movement, I cannot understand how some dogs feel right on the table but the movement is so strange, some dogs move and you only see one rear pad as though the dog is lame but on looking from the side view all the legs are moving. Others have legs which move from the knee instead of the hock – this must mean patella problems! So many with close rear action, this shows narrow pelvis and in bitches is definitely not a good thing.



Topknots do not cover bad heads it does not matter the way you put them up, narrow heads are not camouflaged by a topknot, neither is a course head with a topknot hanging over the eyes.



Lastly where are all these great noses coming from, and I don’t mean length it is the size of the nose leather, when you look into a shih tzu face it should be pretty even in dogs a sweet open expression, the face should not be overpowered by a great fat nose! This is not masculine it is ugly there is no excuse for an ugly shih tzu.











Veteran Dog – 4 (1)



1[sup]st[/sup] - Roberts – BROWNHILLS MY CHOICE – 8 years old gold/white masculine but pleasant expression – good dark eye, well placed nose, excellent pigmentation. Moved soundly keeping his topline and balance.



2[sup]nd[/sup] - Jones’ – ZUTHIS FACT NOT FICTION AMONG CARLITA – 8 years old gold/white another good head with soft expression, dark eye, well placed nose good stop. Moved soundly with enthusiasm happy dog.



3[sup]rd[/sup] - Shaw’s – HARROPINE BONO OF WISEOWLS – 7 years old solid gold again in good order, well covered body with level topline and correct balance – good head with large dark eye and correct nose placement and stop.



Special Puppy – 14 (1)



1[sup]st[/sup] - Owen’s - EGREMONT PRACTICAL MAGIC – Red/white put down in very good order. So nice to go over well covered body with good rear angulation and correct reach of neck balanced by his well carried tail. Moved soundly with confidence.



2[sup]nd[/sup] - Cooke’s – THAISU LUST FOR LIFE – Solid gold well coupled balanced youngster. Good mask, excellent pigmentation and eye. Moved well but not with confidence of first but this will come I am sure.



3[sup]rd[/sup] - Clifford’s ZAMADAR MAJIC POTION – Black/White excellent colour with strong black well marked. Of good size moved well would prefer a softer expression.



Special Junior – 8



At this level this was a very very bad class, therefore I withheld first and second.



3[sup]rd[/sup] – Sullivan’s JANJON CHANCE TO DREAM AT JACQUINTA – Gold/White I thought the nicest in this class – he is sound but needs time to settle in coat but good mouth and head with open expression.



Yearling – 10



1[sup]st[/sup]. Crossley’s SANTOSHA THUNDERBOLT – Black/White well marked dog with excellent black – Wonderful head and I loved his open expression. Broad head with low set ears and wide jaw, large black eye, nose of correct proportion and good stop. Good to go over well covered body with correct rear angulation, not everyone will like his reach of neck but he is balanced, tail is well set on and carried high over his back takes your eye in the ring and on the move. He has real ring presence and a terrific outgoing personality which will take him far. CC and BOB.











2[sup]nd[/sup]. Evans’ SANTABELLA CHEEKI BUDDA – Red/White my type loved him – handsome head with open expression, good jaw, dark eye correct nose placement, ears well set down on wide skull. Level topline, excellent rear angulation which shows on the move. Pleased to give him the RCC.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Stephenson & Broxson’s – ROSARIL STATUS QUO. Sold Black of excellent type and size. So well constructed in well covered condition a pleasure to go over. Good size head wonderful black eye correct jaw. Moved out well, probably difficult to appreciate his attributes from the ringside due to his colour but so much to like.







Post Graduate – 9 (1)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Marachowska and Marachoski – PASSERNOMEN’S MR. BAT HANG. Gold/White. Larger than I would like but everything in good order. Pleasant head and expression, well set ears and good dark eye. Covers the ground with correct angulation and movement.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Bridge’s – SAMPA ABU NORBU – Gold/White of good overall quality. Moves out well with level topline and well set on tail. Head of ample proportions with dark eye and good jaw, nose of correct size and good stop.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Steven’s – PEEKIN TSEMO-TU – Gold/White well marked dog – good balance carries himself well sound on the move. Would prefer a broader more masculine head.



Limit – 15 (2)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Jones’ HARROPINE COMANCHE AMONG CARLITA ShCM – Pale Gold/White masculine dog deserved his win today. Excellent movement from a well balanced strong body, correct angulation front and rear, well carried head on strong neck with well laid shoulders. Lovely expression with wide set eyes and correct jaw.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Cooke’s – THAISU MORNING GLORY VON QUESHIAN – Deep Gold/White another well covered dog with special head and expression, well balanced carries his shape well on the move, moves out well.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Willett’s – DEBEAUX LOVES DEVINE – Gold/White Carries himself so well, put down in excellent order. Well covered body, level topline, good reach of neck on well laid shoulders. Just preferred the more open expression of first two, but lots to like.



Open – 19 (2)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Gray’s BELLWAYCHARM HEAVENLY WUN AT RAGABBEY – Gold/White deserved his win in this class. Pleasant head with wide set ears, correct jaw, well placed nose of correct length and stop, dark wide set eyes. Level topline with good reach of neck balanced by his well set tail. Moved soundly.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Brown’s – ROSSVALE RED EXCESS – Red/White loved his expression – good size head with wide set dark eye. Nose of correct shape and size with good stop. Balanced on the move and stepped out well.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Murrell’s CH JUST DANDY FROM KRISQUEST Gold/White not surprised he has his title a lot to like but would prefer him a bit more masculine.







Good Citizen – 2



1[sup]st[/sup]. Jones’ – ZUTHIS FACT NOT FICTION AMONG CARLITA (2[sup]nd[/sup] in Veteran)



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Swift’s – JIMSAMROBLEE MR MUSCLES Deep Gold/White – Would like more underjaw and a higher set on tail.





Veteran Bitch – 4



1[sup]st[/sup]. Brown’s CH. ROSSEVALE SHE’S BEWITCHING 10 years old Gold/White. Such a pretty head and expression still with good dentition. Moved soundly keeping her shape and level topline.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Carter & Leigh’s – GLADMIN SHAKIA 7 years old Gold/White. This bitch has no problems with movement steps out well keeping her well balanced shape all the time. She has a feminine head and sweet expression have always liked her.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Hitt’s – CH. CEDARHYTHE CLASSIC DESIGN JW ShCM – 10 years old Black/White. Put down in excellent order striking from the ringside with excellent markings. Her failing for me is that she is too narrow in pelvis and therefore close in rear movement.



Special Puppy 14 (2)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Jones’ MIRACEY STAR DANCER FO CARLITA Gold/White. Beautiful head with large dark eye perfect nose placement, wide set ears low on the broad head. Good bone and balance moves well.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Dean’s CHODEAS EASTERN STAR Gold/White. Very close decision between this and first. Another good head, covers the ground well with good angulation in rear. Dare say they will change places on a regular basis.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Hitt’s MIRACEY FRUITY KISSES Gold/White. Smaller in construction and finer made than first 2 but much to like about her. Covers the ground well and in excellent well presented coat.











Special Junior 13 (1)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Williams’ PALIDEN GOOD AS GOLD Solid Gold. Typical solid face and expression. Excellent pigmentation and eye. Nicely coupled body moves soundly with good topline and well carried tail.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Russell’s & Evans MATSUBA DIVINE FANTASY Black/White Very good body and bone – moves out well keeping her topline and well carried tail. I liked her head and expression, wide set ears and dark eye such a nice bitch.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Forbes’ MINFAA STRIKING DIAMONDS TO EKLAND Red/White well presented coat which is striking in colour. Liked her balance and movement. Just would prefer a shorter nose and more underjaw.



Yearling Bitch 13 (1)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Devine’s TANSINGH COLOUR ME BEAUTIFUL FOR MIRAZION. Gold/White old type bitch with broad head and low set ears, well placed dark eye. Moved out well showing her well carried head and tailset. Glad to award her the RCC.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Anderton’s PEKOE STAR ATTRACTION JW. Gold/White bitch. Close decision between this and first. Very well balanced bitch who moves well keeping her topline and tail carriage. Pretty head, good eye and nose placement with excellent stop.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Crossley’s SANTOSHA WARRIOR QUEEN Gold/White not so mature as two above, but is so feminine. Well covered body in excellent coat, moved out very well with good rear drive.



Post Graduate 15 (4)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Ritchie’s LAURMERAND SHINE A LIGHT Sold Black really liked her so compact. Black large eye, excellent pigmentation, wide jaw such a lovely face to look into. Moved soundly.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Richardson’s KATONIER MISS UNDERSTOOD AT BELLAKERNE Black/White what a sweety. Pretty head with such dark eyes, nose of correct proportion and good stop. Beautifully marked and excellent black.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Steven’s PEEKIN SURI-TU Gold/White good size bitch well covered sound in construction. Moved out well. Just preferred heads and expressions of 1[sup]st[/sup] and 2[sup]nd[/sup].

















Limit Bitch 14 (2)



1[sup]st[/sup]. Steven’s PEEKIN ZYRI ZHANG-TU Red/White. Moved out well covers the ground with good rear action. Balanced reach of neck and tail carriage well covered body. Put down in very good coat. Showed herself well.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Anderton’s PEKOE TOO GOOD TO MISS JW. Gold/White another nice size bitch with pretty head and expression. Moved soundly with good level topline and well carried tail.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Wareing & Roberts’ EVALOVE BELLA HE BALL AT KATONIER Black/White Beautifully marked bitch with excellent black. Well laid shoulders, level back well set on high set tail. Real ring presence put down well.







Open 9



1[sup]st[/sup]. Cooke’s CH.THAISU SHE ROCKS Deep Gold/White I think she is a really beautiful bitch – terrific feminine head and expression good dark large eye, correct jaw. So balanced with level topline and good reach of neck, well carried tail. Pleased to give her the CC.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Hitt’s CH MIRACEY FRUITY FANTASY Gold/White well presented bitch of a different type to 1[sup]st[/sup]. More defined reach of neck and tail set, level topline at all times. Preferred head of 1[sup]st[/sup] but all to like.



3[sup]rd[/sup]. Willett’s DEBEAUX TENACIOUS AVEC CHANDLIMORE. Pale Gold/White another nice bitch put down in good order. Moved out well. Pretty head just preferred tail set of 1[sup]st[/sup] and 2[sup]nd[/sup].



Good Citzen – 2



1[sup]st[/sup]. Coupland’s JIMSAMROBLEE MISS HONALULU Solid Gold with good black mask and pretty expression with good nose placement and stop. Reserve in Post Grad.



2[sup]nd[/sup]. Coupland’s JIMSAMROBLEE PRINCESS CLEO Solid Gold very much the same as first but not so attractive in expression.



Pam Woodbridge
Never argue with an idiot. He'll drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Crufts 2012 - Critique - by Adam - 03-17-2012, 12:19 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)