Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
ST Club of Wales & West 2005 Critique
#1
SHIH TZU CLUB OF SOUTH WALES AND WESTERN COUNTIES CHAMPIONSHIP SHOW - Bitch Critiques.



Date: Sunday 20th March 2005. Judge: Emma Gibbons.



I would like to thank the Committee of the Shih Tzu Club of South Wales and Western Counties for inviting me to judge at their Championship show and also for their kind hospitality throughout the day.

Thank you to all of the Exhibitors for allowing me the honour of judging their bitches in such lovely condition and above all for making my first Championship show appointment so enjoyable with their obvious appreciation of my winners....this contributed to the lovely friendly atmosphere of the show...

I was looking for a bitch which not only met the standard but was both sound and honest with no exaggerations and plenty of ‘breed type’. I was lucky to find this in most of my class winners....

sadly, on a more critical note, I was not surprised to feel too many with upright shoulders...the standard calls for the shoulders to be ‘Well laid back’, this allowing the front legs to reach forward on the move. Unfortunately what we are actually seeing in some exhibits is a high-stepping and often stilted action...this may be considered ‘Smart’ by some but is most definitely not true Shih tzu action! Also, an upright shoulder means that the deportment of the dog will be incorrect and the overall shape is affected. Naturally as a result of such shoulder placement I found uncharacteristic necklines with some exhibits almost unable to carry their heads proudly as the standard also calls for.

Whilst I found many with broad jaws and correct bites I was saddened to find some, not only with very narrow jaws but also a few with wry jaws! This must not be encouraged as in severe cases it would be to the detriment of the dogs’ health and well-being.

Unfortunately I found some very short ribcages and some with more Apso-like bodies.

Whilst presentation on the most part was very good, with most shown in lovely coat I was saddened to see that some lacked muscle-tone and firm bodies, it is possible to have both. If your bitches are fit and well muscled not only will their health benefit but they will have a more positive action and show more stamina.

I’m sorry to be critical but the future of this lovely breed is entrusted to us and it is important that we do not lose what many talented breeders before us have striven to achieve.

I must say Thank you for some lovely comments by exhibitors following the judging....For me, judging must not be personal , it is the dogs that are being judged! Indeed, in some classes some lovely bitches had to go cardless...



Veteran (3,1)

1st: Barker & Naulls CH. WYNELLE SING LINNET SING J.W. 9 year old g/w lady. Beautifully balanced both standing and on the move. Lovely expression, nicely laid shoulders, firm body and well angulated hind quarters. Moved with real purpose, could show the youngsters a thing or two! Shown in fabulous coat, which was beautifully presented, a real credit to her owner.

2nd: Brooks SAROSIM KUO CHI TE. 8 year old, g/w. Also shown in lovely condition and with full dentition. Nicely sprung rib. Enthusiastic mover, really enjoying her day out.



Minor Puppy (12,2)

A lovely class of babies…

1st: Bell & Turrells BELLWAYCHARM HEAVENLY TRIO. 8 month old, g/w baby. Lovely head and expression, dark eye and pigment. Broad jaw. Deep chest and well sprung rib of correct length. Well angulated hind quarters. Moved very well. Good tail carriage. Shown in lovely coat.

2nd: Linterns MINGSHU EYE CANDY. 8 month old g/w. Very much a baby. Pretty head and expression. Dark eyes. Broad, well cushioned muzzle. Broad chest and well sprung rib. Nicely angulated hind quarters. In lovely puppy bloom.

3rd: Rutters ETHELSMEAD KEEPING THE FAITH.



Puppy (14,4)

Another class of promising babies…

1st: Burns JENKAPA HARLEQUIN LADY. 11 month old B/w. I loved the shape and size of this young lady. Beautiful head and expression. Lovely dark, well spaced eyes and super pigment. Broad, well cushioned muzzle and tip-tilted nose. Nicely arched neck into pleasing shoulders. Well sprung rib of correct length. Well angulated hind quarters which she used to give a positive action on the move. Lovely tail carriage. I hope she has a bright future, very promising. Best puppy bitch.

2nd: Andertons PEKOE PATENT PENDING. 10 month old br/w. Another who is of ideal size and lovely in profile. Feminine head and expression. Broad jaw and very good dentition. Deep chest and well sprung rib. Again, moving with drive. A shame to meet 1 in such good form, a lovely baby.

3rd: Lees JENADE THE SAFE CRACKER.



Junior (11,4)

1st: Goodwins CHELHAMA MIDNIGHT LACE. 16 month old b/w bitch. Nice head and expression. Broad jaw. Dark, well spaced eyes. Nicely sprung rib. Moved with enthusiasm.

2nd: Stevens PEEKIN GIN PALACE TU. 14 month old g/w. Pretty head. Dark eye and pigment. Nicely bodied. Well angulated hind quarters. Not quite as enthusiastic on the move as 1.

3rd: Matthews PALIDEN RED HOT PEPPER.



Maiden (6,1)

1st: Stevens PEEKIN GIN PALACE TU.

2nd: Lewis-Storey SEADOG BALARINA GIRL.

3rd: Rutters ETHELSMEAD A TASTE OF HONEY.



Novice (7,6)

1st: Culverhouse LYKATH’S ATHELAS.



Graduate (4,1)

1st: Sweeney SANTOSHA VIOLET. g/w. Lovely head and expression. Dark eyes. Broad, well cushioned muzzle. Broad chest and well sprung rib. High tail set. Well angulated hind quarters. Moved well.

2nd: Hutchins SOCORRO BORN TO PERFORME. 21 month old, solid cream. Very sweet head and expression, dark eye and pigment. Well sprung rib. Lovely substance. Nicely angulated hind quarters, just preferred the hind action of 1.

3rd: Bradbury SANTOSHA LUCKY CHARM.



Post graduate. (14,2)

One of the best classes of the day…

1st: Hiltons GALESHI PETITE SIRAH. 20 month old b/w lady. Lovely shape. Beautiful to go over, feminine head and expression, dark eye. Good mouth. Deep chest and well sprung rib. Correctly angulated quarters which she used on the move to give a positive performance. Beautifully presented.

2nd: Warners HASHANAH JUS MY IMAGINATION. 2 yr old g/w. Lovely broad skull and broad, well cushioned muzzle. Deep chest, well sprung rib, table-top topline. Well angulated hind quarters which she used well on the move. Fabulous coat which was well presented. Unfortunately she is carrying a bit too much weight (I know the feeling!)

3rd: Carter & Leighs GLADMIN NANDI.



Minor Limit. (2)

1st: Glover and Granas ANYANG CHINESE WHISPER. 3yr old solid silver grey. Lovely bitch, beautiful broad head, soft expression. Well cushioned muzzle. Broad chest. Very good shoulders and well sprung rib. Well angulated hind quarters which she really used on the move. Nice profile both standing and on the move. Shown in lovely strong coat which was beautifully presented.

2nd: Howlands TANIBET FLOOD ALERT. 4yr old solid gold lady of a smaller type. Most exquisite head and expression. Beautiful dark, expressive eyes. Nice firm body. Lovely tail set. Well angulated hind quarters. Shown in lovely coat and condition…A real gem.



Limit (7,3)

1st: Gregorys MARPALYN CHANELLE. 3yr old g/w. Very feminine head and expression, lovely tip-tilted nose. Dark, well spaced eyes. Nice mouth. Deep chest, well sprung ribs of good length. Quarters well angulated to give positive movement fore and aft, holding her shape on the move.

2nd: Brooks SAROSIM TRIGGERS PRIDE. 3yr old, dark grey and white. Nicely balanced outline which she kept on the move. Feminine head, dark eyes. Well sprung rib. Nicely angulated hind quarters. Steady on the move.

3rd: Murrells KRISQUEST PEACHES AND CREAM.



Open (12,3)

A varied but strong open bitch class….

1st: Spooners CH. CHANIKOS JUSTA DREAM J.W. G,br/w. I really loved this young bitch…Beautiful head and expression, dark, well spaced eyes and super, dark pigment. Very good mouth. Nicely arched neck into well laid shoulders. Good depth of chest and nicely sprung rib. Firm body and excellent muscle. Well angulated hind quarters which she really used on the move. Lovely tail carriage giving a balanced outline. She moved as you would expect and never stopped showing, fabulous outgoing temperament. C.C. and B.I.S (Decision made by the referee, Mrs S Rawlings.)

2nd: Gilkes CH. HASHANAH LOVE UNLIMITED AT ZEEVA. At 5yrs old this lovely gold and white lady, I think is looking her best. Lovely broad skull. Broad, well cushioned muzzle. Nicely muscled neck into well laid shoulders. Well sprung rib, firm body and top- line. Well angulated hind quarters. Positive movement fore and aft. Shown in lovely coat and condition which was well presented. R.C.C and R.B.I.S.(Decision made by referee, Mrs S Rawlings).



Emma Gibbons.
Never argue with an idiot. He'll drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
ST Club of Wales & West 2005 Critique - by Adam - 05-03-2005, 09:46 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)