Home | Contact | Submit Information

2019  2018  2017  2016  2015  

Full Critique for Blackpool 2017

View Full Results

Judge : Mr David Robbins
This critique reflects the judge's opinion
based on what they saw on the day of the show.

Many sincere thanks to my very efficient stewards who are often under rated and who we couldn’t do without. I have judged with one of them stewarding previously and was delighted to see him present in my ring. They were both excellent, making my job very much easier. Many thanks also to the exhibitors for giving me the pleasure of handling some lovely exhibits on my first appointment at this level. I did feel that there were several different types and sizes present, making some classes difficult to judge, but I was delighted with my overall winners. There were some that did not have the desired large round eye (oval in one or two cases), a trait that perhaps should be watched for by breeders. Temperaments however were excellent in all cases and presentation was very good indeed.

Minor Puppy Dog
1stMinfaa Oh Shanandore With SobrietyG/w with correct head shape with good dentition which made for good width of jaw. Nice round dark eye giving a nice expression. Super tail set and moved out well.

Puppy Dog
1stAshmakin Bodacious Smooth for JaxTzu JW ShCM ShCEXG/BM in beautiful bloom. Good head and expression, excellent mouth and jaw, well developed front assembly with super reach of neck and true topline. Moved out with drive.
2ndIsishouse Son And HeirG/w with lovely shaped head, dark eye, good neck into nice topline with good tail carriage and moved out well with drive. Put down in super condition. I would just like a little more of her in size but this is a personal preference

Junior Dog
1stYung Lo’s Who Needs A DressHead of correct shape, dark round eye, good tilt of nose, good ears, lovely rib and bone, excellent tail set, very good on the move with true topline. Best Junior In Breed
2ndCh. Art Made Gene Kelly (Imp Swe)G/w with pleasing head and expression. Nice arch of neck into good topline and super tail carriage. Moved out very well both ways.

Yearling Dog
1stCh. Carlita Reason To Dream JWPleasing head and expression with round eye and nice width of jaw. Nicely ribbed with level topline and high tail set. Moved very well indeed both ways.
2ndSenobles HappyAnother nicely headed dog with good front, nice bone and substance pleasing tail and moved out well in a somewhat restricted ring.

Post Graduate Dog
1stShanjora’s Calisto Boy JWMasculine head with dark eye, good jaw, nice neck into well ribbed body with excellent tail carriage set over a level topline and moved out well.
2ndThaisu Devil In DisguiseB/w who ran the winner very close indeed. Excellent pigment with nice round head and correct eye. Good chest into nice body and topline and another that moved well.

Limit Dog
1stCremefern Double TriggerMy type of Shih Tzu with lovely round head, round eye, good nose, nice width of jaw, with good dentition, well balanced body of good bone and rib and moved out well.
2ndWharfeview Candy ManPressed winner hard with masculine head, dark eye, super pigment, set off by nice body and tail set and covered the ground with ease on the move.

Open Dog
1stCh. Cremefern Sweet Talkin Guy JW ShCMThis was my star of the day. Lovely head and expression set off by large dark eye and good mouth and jaw width and nice tilt of nose. Super reach of neck into good shoulders and topline. Lovely bone and nice spring of rib set off by lovely high tail set. Well balanced throughout and moved well both ways showing rear pads and nice reach at front. CC and BOB. Was very surprised to find out later that I had judged him some 3 years ago at an Open show and gave him group 1.
2ndCh. Miracey All Guns BlazinG/w with super head, eye and mouth. Good chest and nice arch of neck with good topline, nice spring of rib, well balanced and moved very well for RCC

Minor Puppy Bitch
1stCarlita Time to Samba JW6 month eye catching baby with super head and expression. Good pigmentation with correct eye and good mouth. Lovely spring of rib with correct tail and lovely balance. Moved very well over the ground for one so young. Very promising.
2ndKatonier Secrets And DreamsAnother one to watch for in the future., Very similar comments apply having plenty of confidence and again moved out well with drive.

Puppy Bitch
1stCh. Shalehan Yarina For Mifcah JW ShCM10 months with lovely feminine expression, dark round eye, good mouth and jaw, nice depth of chest, excellent bone. Super reach of neck into perfect topline and high tail set. Moved very well, showing pads and plenty of reach at front. A real eye catcher for BPIB and considered hard for RCC.
2ndChotahkees Dark Angel at RossvaleB/w with lovely head and eye, good mouth and nice tilt of nose. Super front and ample bone, Well balanced overall, again moved out with drive and another with a good furure.

Junior Bitch
1stCremefern Lily The PinkG/w with lovely round head and eye on good reach of neck. Well bodied with good tail set making a nice outline. Moved very well indeed.
2ndShorestar Tango FireB/w with nicely proportioned head, very well bodied with nice spring of rib and super overall balance. Moved out OK both ways with correct reach in front.

Post Graduate Bitch
1stPaliden Take That to EklandGood dark round eye and nice tilt of nose giving a lovely expression. Very good bone and rib with super high tail set, good topline and moved well to win a strong class.
2ndCarlita Reason To Love ShCMSimilar type to the winner with excellent rib, body and tail. Well proportioned head with correct eye. And moved very well both ways.

Limit Bitch
1stCh. Rossvale Secret ObsessionG/w eye catching bitch with lovely head of correct proportions in relation to the rest of her. Lovely expression set off by dark round eye and on nice arch of neck into level topline and good tail set. Moved very well for RCC. I just wish there was a little more of her for me but made a lovely picture.
2ndMagracara Miss Dynamite at PennyparadesAnother quality bitch with good head and expression. Correct eye, good jaw, true front being well boned. Nice balance set off by super tail carriage and moved out well with drive.

Open Bitch
1stCh. Zeeva Love Unlimited for Maili JW Sh CMFirst in a class of quality. Aloof bitch with beautiful head, excellent round eye and super pigment. Good front assembly and nice arch of neck into well ribbed body with level topline and super tail set. Put down in full bloom and moved with drive at the front, reaching out well and showing pads at rear. BCC
2ndCh. Miracey Disco InfernoAnother bitch that was well presented. Good overall balance set off by lovely feminine head with correct eye, good mouth and jaw and into good chest. Nicely bodied with super tail carriage and another that moved out very well.