Judging summary for Flag of United Kingdom Mr Matthew Russell

UK appointments since January 2000

Manchu Shih Tzu Society 2 2025

21st September 2025

View show results

Best in Show Ch. Tameron Mr Penhaligons
Dog CC Ch. Tameron Mr Penhaligons
Dog RCC Ch. Santosha Night Shade
Bitch CC Ch. Senousi Love The Dress
Bitch RCC Ch. Santosha Silhouette (UK, Fin)
Best Puppy Miracey Miss Holly Berry JW
Best Veteran Ch. Marpalyn Phab Gold

Show critique

First of all, I would like to thank the exhibitors for such a lovely entry and for the gracious way that the placings were taken. There were some very difficult classes where some dogs were placed down the line, not because they were not of good quality, but due to the dogs they were competing against in that class.
I always use the breed standard when judging as this is the blueprint of what distinguishes the breed from other dogs. The Shih Tzu should be more than a generic dog with a top-knot and teapot handle tail.
The Shih Tzu should be a small dog of good weight due to the bone substance and shape and size of the ribcage. You should be able to fit the palm of your hand between the front legs due to the width of ribcage which should then follow through the rest of the dog. I did find a number of dogs that did not have this, which is concerning. Some dogs were giving a square appearance, which is not what the standard calls for. The Shih Tzu should be slightly longer between withers and point of tail than height at withers, not from point of shoulder to point of buttock.
We should not be looking for swan-necks, but there should be enough neck to carry the head proudly. I was surprised to see that some were quite stuffy in the neck which affected the overall shape.
Lack of width of jaw was a concern on some dogs. I have never been a stickler for 6 teeth between the incisors; it is the width and shape of the jaw that is important which contributes to the expression. White of eye has always been a problem and seems to be ongoing. This also has a detrimental effect on the expression.
I found temperaments on the majority of dogs was very good, which is so important, and the standard of grooming was very high. Please be conscious of what is under the coat as well.

Three Counties 2022

11th June 2022

View show results

Best of Breed Ch. Cedarhythe Majical Destiny
Dog CC Ch. Cedarhythe Majical Destiny
Dog RCC Ch. Tameron Mr Black Is Back
Bitch CC Ch. Tameron Miss Black Opium
Bitch RCC Ch. Yung Lo's Success In A Dress (Swe, Dk, Nor)
Best Puppy Santosha Sunkissed At Miracey

Show critique

I would like to thank the committee for the invitation to judge at their championship show, Bill & Trish Gray for their amazing job as stewards in keeping everything running smoothly, and the exhibitors for entering their dogs for my opinion.
I was very pleased with many of the dogs shown under me, although I was a bit surprised with what I found in others. As the standard calls for, I was looking for small dogs with good bone and body making it a heavy dog for its size. I was pleased to see dogs that were slightly oblong in shape which is exactly what the standard calls for. Compact is never a word that should be used when describing the shape of a Shih Tzu. On the down side, I did find some rounded mouths which were also narrow. The breed standard does call for a wide jaw with a square muzzle. This rounded jaw impacts on the whole expression and is something that I have not seen for many years. Many people talk about 6 teeth on the bottom jaw between the incisors. This is not mentioned in the standard, but something to aim for to give that width of jaw, but only if it is the correct shape in the first place. Lack of chin also seems to be appearing in some dogs. Please remember, this should be shock-headed with a definite stop. I did find some that lacked this stop which sloped to the back of the skull. This gives a totally incorrect head shape. I did find the level of grooming and presentation extremely good.

View show results

Dog CC Ch. Honeyshuchun God of Thunder
Dog RCC Ch. Rossvale All About The Boy
Bitch CC Ch. Yung Lo's Heartbeat (Int, Nor, Swe, UK)
Bitch RCC Tameron Miss Paris
Best Puppy Tameron Miss Paris
Best Veteran Tameron Mr Givenchy

Show critique

Thank you to the committee of the Shih Tzu Club Of South Wales & Western Counties for inviting me to judge their Championship Show, and to Dorothy McIntyre for stewarding for me and keeping the ring running so smoothly. Thank you also to the exhibitors for giving me the honour of judging your dogs, and accepting the placings so sportingly.
In general, I found the grooming and presentation to be of a very high standard, but I was concerned to see in some exhibits to be lacking in body and some narrow fronts. Also, we seem to be losing the lovely powerful rear movement, which is to me, one of the main characteristics of our special breed. Temperaments were very good, which is so important.

View show results

Manchester 2010

22nd January 2010

View show results

Best of Breed Ch. Tameron Mr Black XS
Dog CC Ch. Tameron Mr Black XS
Dog RCC Anibes Bee-Yond Belief (Imp)
Bitch CC Ch. Rosaril Naughty Thoughts
Bitch RCC Ch. Thaisu She Rocks
Best Puppy Ch. Cloughlea The Demon Diva (Ir, Dan, Swe)

Show critique

I would like to thank everyone for the lovely entry, especially when considering it was on a working day at the start of the year. I was also very pleased with the gracious way that my placings were received.

I would like to start this critique with a couple of, what I consider, important points. I found the standard of grooming was very high, and I was very impressed with the muscle tone on the majority of the dogs. However, I would hope that when selecting dogs for showing/breeding, all exhibitors would apply the breed standard, as this is a very clear blue print. The shape of the chest is an important aspect to our breed, as this shows as being stated twice in our breed standard. The forequarters should be as straight as possible, consistent with broad chest being well let down and the chest broad and deep I found a number of dogs, which were very narrow in chest. On some, it was difficult to fit 3 fingers between the front legs, let alone my hand. This then followed through to a slab-sided ribcage with very little depth which, when reading the breed standard, is not correct. The Shih Tzu is supposed to be longer between withers and root of tail than height at withers. We should not be aiming for caterpillars, but I did find some dogs that were almost square in appearance, which is certainly not what the standard is calling for. Having said this, I was very pleased with my final line-ups, and in some classes the placings could change on another day. There are some lovely dogs being shown for which I feel the owners can be extremely proud, even if they did not win 1st prize.