Full critique for Scottish KC (General) 2016

Judge Flag of United Kingdom Mr Mike Gilchrist

This critique reflects the judge’s opinion based on what they saw on the day of the show.

View full results

Show critique

I have delayed submitting this critique for a little while as I wanted to give considered thought to how I wanted to say what I found, and what made me so uncomfortable about it. I am afraid there was no easy way of wrapping it up or being subtle about it, so therefore I will speak as I find. I thought the overall quality of the breed, if in anyway the selection presented to me was typical, has gone backwards in depth since I last judged the breed. I remember as a youngster being dragged off by my mother for what I can only describe as an ’audience’ with Mrs Widdrington. Surprisingly, I as a rather bored and disinterested 12 to 13 yr. old must have taken on board her words, because she said much to impress upon us how important to breed type the head shape and size was. It was this issue that concerned me in almost every class today. There were times when I thought to myself if I were to close my eye, would I know if it was a Shih Tzu or Lhasa Apso head I was examining. As I award CCs in both, I found this hugely worrying, especially for up and coming or trainee (for the want of a better word) Judges of the future. Additionally the head shape can seriously affect the ear set and the true Shih Tzu expression I love so much. I will not labour this point further but I think it is something that exhibitors/breeders who are after all the custodians of the breed should give serious thought to. Generally size and toplines were good with the exception of a few, and one other observation is that there were some which were a little narrow across the pelvis, and those that were, invariably rose to the rear giving an untypical bum high slope. Temperament as usual was excellent.

Dog CC

1st Ch. Tameron Mr Red Edition JW A strong and interesting class but had a great deal of variety in it with regard to true breed type.Ch Tameron Mr Red Edition. If I am to be totally honest, I feel we have not seen the best of this one yet, to my mind he still has a degree of maturing to do, but that said he had all the right parts in all the right places and his construction and breed type I was not able to fault. Where he really excels in on the move. His excellent shoulders allow him the desired forward reach and this is mirrored and complimented in the rear quarters construction, showing a clean set of pads every step of the way. His head shape is exactly as it should be and has a true expression. I was happy to award him the CC but he lost out in the challenge with the bitch on maturity.
2nd Ch. Zamadar Majic Potion for Cedarhythe There was little if anything to fault on this one too, he has quality in all departments, head, neck, shoulders and a rear construction. My only reservation was the density of coat and he lost out on that. Nonetheless a very pleasing example of the breed and a very worthy champion. RCC.

Puppy Dog

1st Ch. Art Made Gene Kelly (Imp Swe) Very impressive young man who entered the ring full of his own self-importance. He has a huge abundant puppy coat which can distort his shape to some degree but the hands on examination led to a correctly made youngster. He has a lovely head, pleasing eye shape and true expression, correct muzzle length. Muscle development for his age was appropriate, keep his topline on the move and standing as it should be, showing a clean set of pads going away, but needs to be watched coming towards, as in his enthusiasm he can lose it very slightly. I would anticipate, providing he stays on track, he should have a bright future. BPD.
2nd Kimevan Cast A Spell Neat, well made dog, pleasing enough in the head, and carries it well. Good eye and expression, with desired muzzle. He has a good ribcage, well ribbed back, slightly slower than the winner in his overall development but still gave him a good run for his money. On the move, he appeared to be very independent of mind, side gait was often excellent but fore and aft tended to be a little less tidy, because he wanted to do it his way or no way.

Junior Dog

1st Niallsday For Your Eyes Only at Trottyveck Very pleasing young dog and well advanced for his 14 months. Pleases in the head, good neck and forechest, nice depth to chest and well ribbed back, carries his topline well and tail is nicely set on and well carried. His movement by and large is good, however there are times when he gets rather over enthusiastic and loses the flow but when settled is very sound, I felt he had much to offer the future.
2nd Isishouse Lord Grantham JW Very much the baby of the class as he has just turned 12 months old, but he is very well put together. Chest and ribs are adequate and in accord with his age but will improve when they spring further. Good head which although he is so young; it is masculine enough to show his gender. He moves well and like the winner I feel he is likely to have a bright future.

Post Graduate Dog

1st Shionah Fireworks Pleasing enough male, just gone 24 months but has further maturing to do. He pleases in the head although it still has further development to do, he possesses a true expression very alert and misses nothing, and aware of his surroundings. He has good length to the muzzle and a nice bite, lovely pigment and shape to eye is correct as is the head carriage. Overall he need time to body up and develop muscle in all the appropriate places. He moves well but the rear is not always quite so positive, which I felt that had he been better muscled; it would have given him better control.
2nd Yazhi Golden Eagle Full sized male but in proportion throughout, leaving no doubt with regard to his gender. Has a good shape to his feet, and stands on them well but lacks a certain amount of refinement on the move, he can be a shade close going away. Broad deep chest with a good forechest, reasonably well ribbed back carries his topline well. Has the correct set of tail and carried it well.

Limit Dog

1st Jardhu Yenroc William of Orange Very neat and tidy of good construction throughout. Like a lot of the Shih Tzus of yesteryear, this is a one which I think will take time to mature, but he had to win the class on his construction alone. Liked his head shape, true in type with a correct expression very noble and dignified in his general appearance although I suspect he has his moments of mischief which shines out in his lovely eyes. His good shoulders and correct rear quarters allow him to move as this breed should. Strongly considered him for the Res CC, however, he allowed his topline to fail when stood as I guess he had become a little bored with the proceedings, but nonetheless a very nice dog indeed.
2nd Ch. Thaisu Public Image Possesses a good overall balance and outline and there is a great deal about him to like, but he was his own worst enemy coming towards because really failed to control his front movement at times. Clearly there are times when he can control it, but he chose not to when it really mattered. He has substantial body development and is well muscled throughout. I felt it was a case of him needing to get his act together rather than needing more maturity etc. Quality dog with good potential, he just needs to realise it and use it to his advantage.

Open Dog

1st Ch. Tameron Mr Red Edition JW A strong and interesting class but had a great deal of variety in it with regard to true breed type.Ch Tameron Mr Red Edition. If I am to be totally honest, I feel we have not seen the best of this one yet, to my mind he still has a degree of maturing to do, but that said he had all the right parts in all the right places and his construction and breed type I was not able to fault. Where he really excels in on the move. His excellent shoulders allow him the desired forward reach and this is mirrored and complimented in the rear quarters construction, showing a clean set of pads every step of the way. His head shape is exactly as it should be and has a true expression. I was happy to award him the CC but he lost out in the challenge with the bitch on maturity.
2nd Ch. Zamadar Majic Potion for Cedarhythe There was little if anything to fault on this one too, he has quality in all departments, head, neck, shoulders and a rear construction. My only reservation was the density of coat and he lost out on that. Nonetheless a very pleasing example of the breed and a very worthy champion. RCC.

Bitch CC

1st Ch. Camelle Chocolate Mousse at Rossvale JW (imp Fin) She caught my eye from the moment she entered the ring because she said &#8217Shih Tzu&#8217 on the very first sight. Nothing about her is overdone or exaggerated, she is simply made correctly and moves as she is supposed to. They eye is not taken by glamour alone, but by quality too. Took the CC with ease in this company and I was happy to make her BOB, and I was delighted that she went on to take Gp4.
2nd Ch. Rossvale Secret Obsession My first view of this one didn&#8217t really do much to impress me, however, the hands on and watching her up her game did, she simply got more confidents and drew herself up to make me take notice. Truly she is going to be an excellent showgirl as she knows when to switch it on when it matters. She has a lovely head piece on her, it is so nicely balanced, good eye and expression, and carries it well on a good neck. She moves like a dream as her construction is there to allow this to happen. Whilst by no means do I think she is finished I was happy to award her the RCC. Also unsurprised to find she is the mother of the BP the qualities are all there too.

Puppy Bitch

1st Rossvale Moonlight N Magic Listening back to my notes on my recorder, my first few words sum her up entirely bang on for everything, all the right things in all the right places. She is one of those dogs that when she comes into the ring you cannot wait to get your hands on her, and when you do, you’re not disappointed. She is not only very self-assured in herself, but equally pleasing and confident on the move, foot perfect every step of the way. Loved her, she is brimming with quality and more than happy to award her the BPB & BP. Certainly one for the future.
2nd Mattadam Sea of Dreams at Miracey Very well put together bitch, but given her colour, black, she need close up examination to confirm. I liked her head and expression; she has the ability to look at you and through you at the same time. However, she has an unfortunate white marking on the front which tends to draw they eye and gives the illusion that her front is not her fortune, but when you watch the footfall it is clear that the front is actually correct. Very steady mover, with a good showing of pads when she goes away and holds her topline well and nicely set on tail with good tail carriage.

Junior Bitch

1st Harropine Special Mirage for Fairlou Very sweet bitch of good proportions throughout. Nicely constructed front and rear but is lacking in muscle over the shoulders to give her proper control at the front, whereas it is much more evident at the rear. When moving she presents a good side gait. Her head in nicely shaped, good eye shape and a very feminine expression. If feel she is going through a growing and development phase at the moment but feel the end product will be worth seeing, as she has a lot of potential.
2nd Polmac Dont Stop Me Now Another going through a growing and development phase at the moment, but overall assets could not be denied. She was somewhat hesitant on the table but far more confident when on the move and presented a much more together account of herself. Pretty head of correct expression but now needs further body and muscle to be able to show herself off to the best advantage, nonetheless I fell she should finish well.

Post Graduate Bitch

1st Ch. Rossvale Secret Obsession My first view of this one didn&#8217t really do much to impress me, however, the hands on and watching her up her game did, she simply got more confidents and drew herself up to make me take notice. Truly she is going to be an excellent showgirl as she knows when to switch it on when it matters. She has a lovely head piece on her, it is so nicely balanced, good eye and expression, and carries it well on a good neck. She moves like a dream as her construction is there to allow this to happen. Whilst by no means do I think she is finished I was happy to award her the RCC. Also unsurprised to find she is the mother of the BP the qualities are all there too.
2nd Thaisu Vampire Kisses for Marbo Carries a lovely head piece on her and generally is well constructed but she need to convert a lot of her weight in to muscle as this really shows on the move as she tends to roll a little, she has good front and rear quarters, sound and positive on the move but is not quite as free flowing as the winner.

Limit Bitch

1st Ch. Camelle Chocolate Mousse at Rossvale JW (imp Fin) She caught my eye from the moment she entered the ring because she said &#8217Shih Tzu&#8217 on the very first sight. Nothing about her is overdone or exaggerated, she is simply made correctly and moves as she is supposed to. They eye is not taken by glamour alone, but by quality too. Took the CC with ease in this company and I was happy to make her BOB, and I was delighted that she went on to take Gp4.
2nd Ch. Zeeva Love Unlimited for Maili JW Sh CM Although today was not her opportunity to shine, I feel it will come in time. She has a good head which is well furnished, very pleasing expression, correct in the front and rear construction, and firm topline standing and moving. There is nothing about her I would wish to change other than she needs a shade more maturity to finish the picture. Pushed hard for the RCC.

Open Bitch

1st Ch. Miracey Disco Inferno Very glamorous and will presented. She does not have the head of CC or RCC winners but it does not distract they eye from the rest of her construction. Her undoubted quality comes into play when she moves, free flowing with drive and a clean set of pads every step of the way and she has a distinct advantages of knowing when to use it.
2nd Ch. Tameron Miss Black Opium In retrospect I have wondered if I was not a little hard on this bitch today, she has a lovely head piece, carries it well, and the construction the breed standard calls for. However, my stumbling block with her was that to my eye she lack a little in maturity and in turn did not have the body and muscle I was looking for. That said I feel when she is fully mature so is going to be a real force to be reckoned with because she has all the right things in the right places and can only but have a bright and glittering future, I am not surprised she already holds her title, but I think the future will bring far more exciting things.

in Group

Res Ch. Camelle Chocolate Mousse at Rossvale JW (imp Fin) She caught my eye from the moment she entered the ring because she said &#8217Shih Tzu&#8217 on the very first sight. Nothing about her is overdone or exaggerated, she is simply made correctly and moves as she is supposed to. They eye is not taken by glamour alone, but by quality too. Took the CC with ease in this company and I was happy to make her BOB, and I was delighted that she went on to take Gp4.

Best of Breed

1st Ch. Camelle Chocolate Mousse at Rossvale JW (imp Fin) She caught my eye from the moment she entered the ring because she said &#8217Shih Tzu&#8217 on the very first sight. Nothing about her is overdone or exaggerated, she is simply made correctly and moves as she is supposed to. They eye is not taken by glamour alone, but by quality too. Took the CC with ease in this company and I was happy to make her BOB, and I was delighted that she went on to take Gp4.

Best Puppy

1st Rossvale Moonlight N Magic Listening back to my notes on my recorder, my first few words sum her up entirely bang on for everything, all the right things in all the right places. She is one of those dogs that when she comes into the ring you cannot wait to get your hands on her, and when you do, you’re not disappointed. She is not only very self-assured in herself, but equally pleasing and confident on the move, foot perfect every step of the way. Loved her, she is brimming with quality and more than happy to award her the BPB & BP. Certainly one for the future.