Full critique for City of Birmingham 2016
Show critique
Thanks to the Birmingham committee for the invite to judge and the friendly hospitality given to myself and Vicky. A big thank you to my efficient stewards Dorothy and Glenda who kept me in check also many thanks to the exhibitors for their trust in me to assess their treasures. I had a lovely day, I hope the ring side critics could follow my placings, looking at my line ups I was pleased that I was able to find exhibits that fitted the breed standard. Scanning my results I noted that four of my first placing were sired by the same dog and produced similar type off springs to different bitches. Having said that movement still needs working on, if it’s not addressed soon, up and coming judges will never see the correct movement of our lovely breed and it will be gone forever.
Dog CC
| 1st | Ch. Keytor All That Jazz | What can I say about this young man that hasn’t already been said. No secret that I’ve been a big fan from the first moment I set eyes on him. He has a lovely compelling expression, dark eyes that melt your heart strings, strong jaw with good dentition. The head proportions fit the standard, nose ratio to skull correct. Well arched neck of correct length laying onto a level back. Quarters of correct length and angulation, good stifle which all combined to ensure strong flowing movement lacking in a lot of exhibits today. Good front extension strong driving from the rear. Coat presentation first class as always from this small kennel, a worthy champion pleased to award him C.C. and later B.O.B. |
| 2nd | Gladmin Transkei Teddy JW | Another youngster I’ve admired from the ring side he didn’t disappoint. I thought from an early age that his movement was good. Combined with a nice expression, dark eyes, good dentition and wide jaw was the icing on the cake. I was not disappointed with his body construction, watching his movement had confirmed what his conformation would be like. With the right judges he will have a promising future. In good coat, well presented. Pleased to award him R.C.C. |
Minor Puppy Dog
| 1st | Minfaa Take Me To the Limit at Middletune | Nice baby, good size head, dark eye, pleasing jaw. Coat of good texture covering a strong body which is developing well. Good balanced outline standing and on the move, one to watch for in the future. Nicely presented. |
| 2nd | Marpalyn God Of Mischief for Honeyshuchun | Nice puppy, cute expression, dark eye, good jaw. Similar comments as one they will change places I’m sure. |
Puppy Dog
| 1st | Ch. Carlita Reason To Dream JW ShCM | I’ve admired this young man from the ringside lovely to go over. Nice size head dark eye, wide jaw. Moved well holding a level top line. Lovely presentation, Best Dog Puppy his future looks good. |
| 2nd | Miracey All You Need Is Love For Tilbe JW ShCM VW | This little lad has the most appealing head of good size. Dark eyes correct stop and ear placement. Body maturing nicely, just needs to tighten up. Good presentation. |
Junior Dog
| 1st | Gladmin Transkei Teddy JW | Another youngster I’ve admired from the ring side he didn’t disappoint. I thought from an early age that his movement was good. Combined with a nice expression, dark eyes, good dentition and wide jaw was the icing on the cake. I was not disappointed with his body construction, watching his movement had confirmed what his conformation would be like. With the right judges he will have a promising future. In good coat, well presented. Pleased to award him R.C.C. |
| 2nd | Niallsday For Your Eyes Only at Trottyveck | Unlucky to meet one in such good form. Another nice young man. Nice head good eye, smaller in stature than one and lighter boned. Good balanced tail to head good rear quarters needs to tighten up in front but he is only young this will come. Nice presentation. |
Graduate Dog
| 1st | Ch. Matsonic Chasing Storms to Bishbow JW (GB CH) | Lovely head on this boy, darkest of eyes with a nice nose placement, wide jaw, ears low set. Strong body heavy boned, good length and depth of rib. Well balanced, high tail set, profuse strong coat well presented. |
| 2nd | Shanjora's Calisto Boy JW | This boy was a nice size for me and nearer what the standard requires. Ample bone a good rib with depth. Nice head on a strong neck set on level top line. Moved round the ring with purpose in good coat. |
| Res | Shirkeira I Want It All JW ShCM | Stood alone but gave a good account of himself. Nice expression, good temperament. Nicely presented moved well round the ring enjoying his day out. |
Post Graduate Dog
| 1st | Ch. Sistasu Silver Lining JW ShCM | Conforms to the standard but of the larger type. Strong body, well developed. Good quarters, well-muscled in a nice well-presented coat. Nicely balanced head and tail giving a pleasing outline. Moved with drive. |
| 2nd | Peekin Archie Tu | One of the smaller type but nearer to the size I like. Nice head with dark eyes, strong jaw. Correct placed ears heavy plumed. Nicely arched neck onto a good shoulder placement. Nice length and depth of rib for his size. Good quarters which he used to drive round the ring in style. Well presented. |
Limit Dog
| 1st | Ch. Weatsom Margarets Legacy for Quingshui JW ShCM | This was a strong but very mixed class, some very heavy dogs or high on the leg.This attractive dog looks the part. He has a beautiful head, with soft melting dark eyes. A tipped tilted nose, for me without it the expression isn’t Shih Tzu. The quarters are well angulated and used well to flow round the ring. Nice presentation strongly considered for top honours, another day another judge. |
| 2nd | Cremefern Double Trigger | Nice honest dog, pleasing head with lovely dark eyes, tipped up nose, good jaw. Good quarters nicely muscled, level back. Correct head to tail balance. Moved with panache in good jacket, well presented. |
Veteran Dog
| 1st | Tameron Mr Givenchy | Stood alone but a worthy winner. He has an attractive head of a good size it filled my hand, well proportioned. Nice dark eyes, correct ear placement. Well-proportioned body, firm muscle. Nicely balanced dog, well set tail, in good coat. One of the better movers, good presentation. |
Good Citizen Scheme Dogs
| 1st | Shirkeira I Want It All JW ShCM | Stood alone but gave a good account of himself. Nice expression, good temperament. Nicely presented moved well round the ring enjoying his day out. |
Open Dog
| 1st | Ch. Keytor All That Jazz | What can I say about this young man that hasn’t already been said. No secret that I’ve been a big fan from the first moment I set eyes on him. He has a lovely compelling expression, dark eyes that melt your heart strings, strong jaw with good dentition. The head proportions fit the standard, nose ratio to skull correct. Well arched neck of correct length laying onto a level back. Quarters of correct length and angulation, good stifle which all combined to ensure strong flowing movement lacking in a lot of exhibits today. Good front extension strong driving from the rear. Coat presentation first class as always from this small kennel, a worthy champion pleased to award him C.C. and later B.O.B. |
| 2nd | Ch. Cremefern Sweet Talkin Guy JW ShCM VW | This is another lovely boy, unlucky to meet one in such good form. He has a nice expression with dark eye, good jaw, correct ear set. Good arch to neck, good length and depth of rib. In lovely coat well presented, moved with purpose. |
Bitch CC
| 1st | Ch. Rosaril Naughty Moments with Bishbow | Solid gold with the right expression, solids are the most difficult heads to get right. They tend to have a bland expression or a dull look in their eyes, get it right they melt your heart. This lovely lady’s eyes searched your soul. The darkest of eyes, complimented by the tipped tilted nose and wide jaw completed the picture of an oriental beauty. Icing on the cake, lovely outline, well angulated quarters, moving with panache. A profuse coat beautifully presented. My bitch C.C. winner. |
| 2nd | Ch. Cloughlea One Step Beyond Dolha | A worthy champion, pretty head, soft expressive eyes. Good conformation with deep well sprung rib, level back and well set tail. Higher on the leg than one but within the standard. Lovely coat well presented completed the picture. My R.C.C. |
Minor Puppy Bitch
| 1st | Ch. Tameron Miss Dark Obsession | What a sweetie, liked her when I first saw her, but now as she is growing up she has more appeal. Lovely head, dark mischievous eyes. Quarters conform to the standard so her movement for one so young was good. She reached at the front and had strong rear drive showing a good full pad. Balance was pleasing with head and tail nicely balanced unaided. Coat coming along nicely, will have a promising future. Presentation second to none as expected from this kennel, pleased to award her Best Puppy |
| 2nd | Cremefern Lily The Pink | Again a lovely puppy, unlucky to meet one in such good form. Again a striking head, well balanced body, nice conformation enabling her to move correctly. Coat coming along nicely, presented well, will have a good future. |
| Res | Furry Team Neanta Bella (imp) | Nice little babe a bit shy at first but when she moved she gained confidence and strutted her stuff. Nice eyes and jaw. Good balance level topline, her body needs to tighten up but she is only a baby, that will come with time. Coat coming along nicely. Moved well. |
| VHC | Chesvet Line K Queen Star for Suzitzu (imp Russia) | This madam has a will of her own and was not at one with her handler. Hard to handle, on the floor she did improve enough for me to place her. She will need a lot of training with patience. Good Luck. |
Puppy Bitch
| 1st | Furry Team Neanta Bella (imp) | Nice little babe a bit shy at first but when she moved she gained confidence and strutted her stuff. Nice eyes and jaw. Good balance level topline, her body needs to tighten up but she is only a baby, that will come with time. Coat coming along nicely. Moved well. |
| 2nd | Chesvet Line K Queen Star for Suzitzu (imp Russia) | This madam has a will of her own and was not at one with her handler. Hard to handle, on the floor she did improve enough for me to place her. She will need a lot of training with patience. Good Luck. |
Junior Bitch
| 1st | Matsonic Gotta Have Faith at Ethelsmead | A little larger than I like for a bitch, but the conformation was good allowing even movement with good rear drive. Strong head, nice eyes that looked back at me. Well balanced, in good jacket. |
| 2nd | Harropine Special Mirage for Fairlou | Smaller than one, more my size. Good head, dark eyes, adequate jaw. Conformation and balance good, set of tail correct. Coat coming along nicely. Moved with a good driving action. |
Veteran Bitch
| 1st | Ch. Marhilway She's Got The Edge ShCM | This 8 yr. old lady is a worthy champion she can hold her own with the best. Lovely head very feminine, dark eyes. Good quarters nice angulation, level back. Correct rib, proportional in depth and length, well balanced tail to head, giving a pleasing outline. In good jacket, well presented was in contention for top honours. My Best Veteran. |
| 2nd | Ch. Bellwaycharm High Flyer for Tilbe JW ShCM | I made this lady a champion, she too is a worthy one. Still love her but she was not moving as well today and one was on top form, a hard decision for me. She was in lovely condition a credit to her owner. Splitting hairs because I love the third as well. Three lovely bitches all worthy champions. |
Graduate Bitch
| 1st | Rossvale Xquisite Model at Sannivek | Nice little bitch, nice expression. Good balance head to tail ample rib for her size, quarters proportional for her body. In nice coat, well presented. Moved ok. |
| 2nd | Suzitzu Lady Diana | This little madam has a will of her own and was not at one with her handler. On the table she was a nightmare, she was better on the floor but does not like being handled. I assessed her on her movement which she performed enough for me to place her. She needs training with patience, good luck. |
Post Graduate Bitch
| 1st | Chanikos Dreams A Brewin | Of good size with a pleasing head, nice dark eyes, wide jaw. Correct arched neck onto a good lay of shoulder. Adequate length and depth of rib with a nice high tail set. In good textured coat moved with style, considered for top honours. |
Limit Bitch
| 1st | Peekin Peek-A-Boo-Tu | Smaller type but very feminine, lovely dark eyes tipped up nose, top knot needs to relax, spoilt the expression. Good angulated quarters so well put together. Level top line, high tail, moved with purpose today not putting a foot wrong. I’ve seen her ruin her chances by being stubborn, very happy today. |
| 2nd | Tansingh Angel and Demon | Nice head pleasing expression. Front conformation a little upright in shoulder which spoilt the extension that I look for. She did give a good account of herself, was presented well and enjoyed her showing. |
Open Bitch
| 1st | Ch. Rosaril Naughty Moments with Bishbow | Solid gold with the right expression, solids are the most difficult heads to get right. They tend to have a bland expression or a dull look in their eyes, get it right they melt your heart. This lovely lady’s eyes searched your soul. The darkest of eyes, complimented by the tipped tilted nose and wide jaw completed the picture of an oriental beauty. Icing on the cake, lovely outline, well angulated quarters, moving with panache. A profuse coat beautifully presented. My bitch C.C. winner. |
| 2nd | Ch. Cloughlea One Step Beyond Dolha | A worthy champion, pretty head, soft expressive eyes. Good conformation with deep well sprung rib, level back and well set tail. Higher on the leg than one but within the standard. Lovely coat well presented completed the picture. My R.C.C. |
Best of Breed
| 1st | Ch. Keytor All That Jazz | What can I say about this young man that hasn’t already been said. No secret that I’ve been a big fan from the first moment I set eyes on him. He has a lovely compelling expression, dark eyes that melt your heart strings, strong jaw with good dentition. The head proportions fit the standard, nose ratio to skull correct. Well arched neck of correct length laying onto a level back. Quarters of correct length and angulation, good stifle which all combined to ensure strong flowing movement lacking in a lot of exhibits today. Good front extension strong driving from the rear. Coat presentation first class as always from this small kennel, a worthy champion pleased to award him C.C. and later B.O.B. |
Best Puppy
| 1st | Ch. Tameron Miss Dark Obsession | What a sweetie, liked her when I first saw her, but now as she is growing up she has more appeal. Lovely head, dark mischievous eyes. Quarters conform to the standard so her movement for one so young was good. She reached at the front and had strong rear drive showing a good full pad. Balance was pleasing with head and tail nicely balanced unaided. Coat coming along nicely, will have a promising future. Presentation second to none as expected from this kennel, pleased to award her Best Puppy |
Best Veteran
| 1st | Ch. Marhilway She's Got The Edge ShCM | This 8 yr. old lady is a worthy champion she can hold her own with the best. Lovely head very feminine, dark eyes. Good quarters nice angulation, level back. Correct rib, proportional in depth and length, well balanced tail to head, giving a pleasing outline. In good jacket, well presented was in contention for top honours. My Best Veteran. |