Judging Summary for Mrs Pat Maule
UK Appointments since January 2000
| LKA 2025 | Date : 13th December 2025 | ||||||||||||||
|
LKA has been Top of my Judging Bucket List for over 3 decades so I was thrilled to be invited for 2025. Thank you to my very efficient Stewards, Sharon and Wayne. Thank you, exhibitors, for entering and accepting my placings with Good Grace, another day, a different venue and the results could be very different. Today I felt the strength of the Breed was in the males, open and limit full of quality, minor puppy with exciting new prospects starting out on their show careers. Open bitch teeming with mature, quality exhibits. Hind action leaves much to be desired, single tracking, lacking drive and essential kick up showing full pads. Still far too many small, light eyes. Mucky eyes detract from the overall expression. Presentation surprised me, knots/matts are not acceptable. |
| Paignton 2022 | Date : 7th August 2022 | ||||||||||||||
|
| Crufts 2017 | Date : 10th March 2017 | ||||||||||||
|
Thank you exhibitors for an amazing entry in both numbers and quality. All exhibits were presented clean and tangle free and handling was, in the main, exemplary. Inevitably in an entry of this size, 193 exhibits making 214 entries, more exhibitors would leave the ring disappointed than those who received a place card. Exhibits who won had won CCs and Reserve CCs in the past were competing against different dogs today, so inevitably, many results were different. Crufts is a show unlike any other in the UK and not all dogs [or handlers] perform at their best in the razzmatazz atmosphere. I was looking for dogs with the characteristics that make the Shih Tzu unique: round skull, well spaced, round, dark eyes, wide muzzle, sturdy, broad chest, "tea pot tail", forward reach with powerful hind action, showing full pads. And, most important, that arrogant yet inquisitive attitude, plus that extra "sparkle" to stand out in a crowd Not many black & whites in today’s entry and on the whole I found them to be the most disappointing, so many showing white in not only one but both eyes coupled with a "scared, timid" attitude on the table. Mouths were very mixed, most with good width of jaw and just undershot but more than I expected that are "spoon shaped" coupled with lack of chin. Beautiful dogs in glorious coat but outline spoilt by "flat tails". Rear action disappointing, the drive is there but not showing full pads, this was in some cases due to excessive length of coat. Forward reach more of a problem, short upper arm restricting free flowing "ship in full sail" action. |
| Richmond 2014 | Date : 07th September 2014 | ||||||||||||
|
| Bournemouth 2012 | Date : 11th August 2012 | ||||||||||||||
|
| Boston & District CS 2011 | Date : 9th January 2011 | ||||||||||||
|
| Welsh KC 2008 | Date : 17th August 2008 | ||||||||||||
|
| Shih Tzu Club 2005 | Date : 8th October 2005 | ||||||||||||
|
| WELKS 2003 | Date : 27th April 2003 | ||||||||||||
|
Mouths were acceptable, but small & or light eyes do not appear to have improved. Large dark eyes are such an essential part of the Shih Tzu's make up, giving that I'm alive & looking for mischief look. Temperaments gave me a great deal of concern. What has happened to the friendly & independent requirement of the Standard? Instead of classes full of self possessed, confident, arrogant, outgoing exhibits far too many really didn't want to be at the show. Stiff tense bodied under my hands, wary expression & lacking enthusiasm on the move. One adult bitch snapped at my hand. All dogs whether show or companions live with people & should have friendly, reliable temperaments. Presentation & coat do not compensate for faulty construction or tippy toe movement but with two minutes per exhibitor allowed for assessment, time spent channelling the breed's natural show off attitude to make themselves stand out in a crowd is an obvious advantage particularly in the higher classes where several dogs are competing for top honours. I fail to understand why so many dogs are not groome d underneath, clumps of matted coat are neither pleasant to feel or comfortable for the dog. Pleased to see youngsters being given the opportunity to handle exhibits with potential, giving them, I hope, encouragement to stay in the breed. |
| Birmingham 2000 | |||||||||||
|